the plot thickens
English • United States
An expression originally used when something is introduced to the plot in a novel, movie, etc., to make it more complicated or interesting, but is now also used outside that context to indicate a set of circumstances has become more complex, mysterious, interesting, or difficult to understand.
"Remember I told you I keep finding rubber ducks at my doorstep?"
"Yeah?"
"Turns out the same thing is happening to my sister!"
"Wow, the plot thickens"